Hrmm interesting topic well i honestly think its nearly almost always accurate with a few exceptions maybe a few tweaks could be made here and there but i think they have a done a good job.
One think i noticed elo does not take into account factors such as sometimes i vs 1500 elo me 1600 elo but they hold me for a long time and i punish them and it ends that the lane player against me is then punished and are penalized most when they loose,but elo does not take into account the ability of me or how well he did to hold me of for so long for example when no one his team could of done better.Elo sometimes screws someone who has the hardest jobs often happens with support play.
It just doesn't show which kills your assisted in some players are usually harder to kill or the kill it self turned the game etc.If you assist in killing a weak player not much but when you ganking or killing a better player its more vital to the end result of the game.
I don't know if the elo takes into account the amount of times you defended a cp sometimes some good players have no ability to see a cp battle coming or defend.But still get 0.15 or 1.00 because of other statistics even though defending cps is just as important.
Sometimes playing guard gives you no kills etc or not much creeps but assit the team alot .Even deaths defending a cp alone or team mates not helping.Even orbital gives large aoe damage item usually played with hunter but often the other players are just standing there pick up the kills.Just a few examples
Btw these are just a few thoughts im sure there are many others i which will come up.
I know what you mean though it happens however.I don't know if any of my comments can give way to some suggestions.How about having a little more weighing on other factors im not sure just a suggestion i am quite happy with the elo system
One think i noticed elo does not take into account factors such as sometimes i vs 1500 elo me 1600 elo but they hold me for a long time and i punish them and it ends that the lane player against me is then punished and are penalized most when they loose,but elo does not take into account the ability of me or how well he did to hold me of for so long for example when no one his team could of done better.Elo sometimes screws someone who has the hardest jobs often happens with support play.
It just doesn't show which kills your assisted in some players are usually harder to kill or the kill it self turned the game etc.If you assist in killing a weak player not much but when you ganking or killing a better player its more vital to the end result of the game.
I don't know if the elo takes into account the amount of times you defended a cp sometimes some good players have no ability to see a cp battle coming or defend.But still get 0.15 or 1.00 because of other statistics even though defending cps is just as important.
Sometimes playing guard gives you no kills etc or not much creeps but assit the team alot .Even deaths defending a cp alone or team mates not helping.Even orbital gives large aoe damage item usually played with hunter but often the other players are just standing there pick up the kills.Just a few examples
Btw these are just a few thoughts im sure there are many others i which will come up.
I know what you mean though it happens however.I don't know if any of my comments can give way to some suggestions.How about having a little more weighing on other factors im not sure just a suggestion i am quite happy with the elo system
Cat power < needs to be implemented into bt
Accounts are : , Imba_Kitten, DJ.FM,BENNIE.FM
Accounts are : , Imba_Kitten, DJ.FM,BENNIE.FM