Official Battle Tanks Community
[8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - Printable Version

+- Official Battle Tanks Community (https://btanks.net/forum)
+-- Forum: Battle Tanks - Warcraft III (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Bug Reports (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=13)
+---- Forum: Solved (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+---- Thread: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it (/showthread.php?tid=251)



[8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - ssl - 2010-10-30

Just played a game. We had a feeder, stats 0-6, but we couln't kick him. Enemy team successfully kicked yellow with stats 0-1 and only 2 votes needed!!! We were finally able to kick ours with stats 0-9 and still 3 votes needed, so what the hell is wrong here? I attached the replay.


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - Ger-Dyers-Eve - 2010-10-30

To Quote the new kick-system:

each kill: -1
each death: +2
each minute afk: +8
each gametime minute -0.75
Every Vote by 5 Players: +10
Threshold to kick: 50

Stats 0-6:
6*2=12
Your Votes: 40 (i havent read the replay, but i think, you all would have kicked him)
-----
52

BUT: 52-Gametime => below 50 and so unkickable.

0-9 and still 3 votes needed
9*2=18
your Votes: 40
----------
58

But: 58-Game+AFK-Time => over 50 and so kickable.


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - ssl - 2010-10-30

No, we could not initiate a vote against him with him having 0-6. Its not that the vote failed but instead it sayed "this player is not kickable". Also this doesn't explain why the other palyer could be kicked with 0-1 stats and only with 2 votes. There must be a bug here.


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - Ger-Dyers-Eve - 2010-10-30

Quote:Also this doesn't explain why the other palyer could be kicked with 0-1 stats and only with 2 votes.

you know, that the threshold is going down by 8 every minute you are afk in game? Maybe he was afk.

Example:

3 Minutes afk=24
0-1 Stats:2
4 Votes: 40
5 Minutes Gametime: -3,75
-------
62,25 = kickable
2 Minutes: 54,25=kickable


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - Exodus - 2010-10-30

He wasn't afk, the Kick system is still somehow bugged, although I don't know yet where the fault is. It's not that much code to check and everything looks fine so far, but it still somehow screws up sometimes.


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - ssl - 2010-10-30

Ger-Dyers-Eve Wrote:4 Votes: 40
Do you guys even read what I am writing?


Re: [8.72b] new kick system: I dont get it - Ger-Dyers-Eve - 2010-10-30

ssl Wrote:
Ger-Dyers-Eve Wrote:4 Votes: 40
Do you guys even read what I am writing?
sorry, dont read the "3 votes still needed" Sad