+- Official Battle Tanks Community (https://btanks.net/forum)
+-- Forum: Battle Tanks - Warcraft III (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Bug Reports (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=13)
+---- Forum: Solved (https://btanks.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=20)
+---- Thread: kicksystem bug (/showthread.php?tid=2771)
kicksystem bug - Fubupairs - 2011-05-17
Hello guys, in my opinion the kick system has a massive bug or I don't understand the system anymore.
In minute 50-51 I tried to kick orange (Ch4oSxD) at 6 kills and 21 death. That was not possible.
In minute 52-53 I tried it a second time at 8/21, but it failed a second time. In the same minute orange started a kick vote against me and was successfull. But my score was 16/15.
Plz explaine me, how this can be.
RE: kicksystem bug - eSVau - 2011-05-17
(2011-05-02, 00:20:31)Exodus Wrote: Ok then, I'll try to explain this.
Each player starts with 0 points on his own kick account. The threshold for a successful kick is 50, while a vote from a single player is worth 10 points (assuming there are 5 players in your team).
When trying to kick a specific player, the points from the votes and the points from the kick account are added up.
This means, you can't kick a player, who has no points on this account. There are only two factors influencing this account: the afk time and the players deaths.
When you die, a death penalty is added to your kick account. In the current version, this value is set initially to 2.5 (so the 4 is outdated). After that, this penalty is increased by 1. So if you die again right after that, a penalty of 3.5 is added to your account.
Both the penalty value and the points on your account decrease with time (points added from being afk are excluded from this). The system is designed in a way, that both of these values reach their initial state after 3 minutes. If you happen to die again in this time frame, both values are increased again and now take longer to decrease to their initial state.
We chose the time of 3 minutes, because that's the average time between two deaths in the league.
You get 5 points on your kick account for each minute your are afk.
As you might have guessed, a kick is first possible, when you have 10 points on your kick account. Your team needs four yes votes to kick you then. With 20 points on the account, they only need 3 votes, etc. The kick account is limited at 40 points, since one vote is required to be able to kick (obviously).
I hope this clears things up a little.
RE: kicksystem bug - Fubupairs - 2011-05-17
I know the system, but how is it possible that a guy with 21 deaths and a ratio of 0,38:1 cann't be kicked, but me with 15 deaths and a ratio of 1,07:1 can?
"There are only two factors influencing this account: the afk time and the players deaths."
No one was afk!
RE: kicksystem bug - Tynkywinky - 2011-05-17
(2011-05-17, 19:20:22)Fubupairs Wrote: I know the system, but how is it possible that a guy with 21 deaths and a ratio with 0,38:1 cann't be kicked, but me with 15 deaths and a ratio of 1,07:1 can?
"There are only two factors influencing this account: the afk time and the players deaths."
No one was afk!
Have you thought about how often you died? Time has something to do with it.
RE: kicksystem bug - Fubupairs - 2011-05-17
I wrote the number of death, or do you mean a death sequenze and not the number?
But easily watch the replay and you know, that there is something wrong.
RE: kicksystem bug - eSVau - 2011-05-17
*sign* why do i even searched for exos explaination if it isn't read nor understood
RE: kicksystem bug - Fubupairs - 2011-05-17
Maybe I'm too stupid too understand the kick rules. But if the rules says, that a feeder cann't be kicked, but a player with posive stats can be kicked, they are crap.
RE: kicksystem bug - Helge_F - 2011-05-17
a guy who misses kills (many assist) and die every five minutes will have 0:20 after an hour
a solo player with positiv stats rules his lane dont help the team lets give him 30:10 after 50 min then he rushes always the base kills a building and dies (high bounty) and have 30:20 at an hour
wich one would u like to kick, who is better for the team ? he might have positiv stats but is seriusly feeding so u can kick him
btw not the "bug" in the kick system kicked u... it was ure team so think about it
RE: kicksystem bug - Fubupairs - 2011-05-17
(2011-05-17, 22:55:24)Helge_F Wrote: btw not the "bug" in the kick system kicked u... it was ure team so think about itI didn't get kicked, only the vote started. So i see even you didn't watched the replay.
RE: kicksystem bug - Helge_F - 2011-05-18
kick orange.w3g (Size: 2.4 MB / Downloads: 0)
maybe....
otherwise everyone exept u knows whats going on so why watching a replay without a bug
if u dont get kicked it is no problem, u just see the kick system works. and if u want to kick such a feeder u have to w8 that he dies 4 time in a row under 3 min then he is kickable
RE: kicksystem bug - Tynkywinky - 2011-05-18
(2011-05-18, 01:18:25)Helge_F Wrote: kick orange.w3g (Size: 2.4 MB / Downloads: 0)
maybe....
otherwise everyone exept u knows whats going on so why watching a replay without a bug
if u dont get kicked it is no problem, u just see the kick system works. and if u want to kick such a feeder u have to w8 that he dies 4 time in a row under 3 min then he is kickable
Did u forgot to attach the file? cuz I can't see any replay.
RE: kicksystem bug - eSVau - 2011-05-18
(2011-05-18, 14:54:28)Tynkywinky Wrote: Did u forgot to attach the file? cuz I can't see any replay.
He quoted the replay of the opening post