Poll: Should we disregard K-D and make extra game for Seig-GeiL, OldSchool, Oldscotch?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes, using K-D as a factor is bad. We should fix it now to make rematch. Otherwise it is unfair for Oldschotch.
47.22%
17 47.22%
No, maybe K-D is bad, but the tournament has started. We should stick to the existing rules and accept the fact Oldscotch is ranked 3rd.
52.78%
19 52.78%
Total 36 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 2 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
[vote] K-D is a bad factor for ranking teams. Should we fix it now with rematch?
#86
sorry but i think this all is going in a direction which i cant be happy with.

everyone knows the current status:
1. oldschool
2. sieg-geil
3. oldscotch

facts:
1) sieg-geil wont do a rematch so they already in and if there will be a rematch between olds they can only win (first place or just stay where they are place two) - ofc they dont wanna play anymore and i totally agree with their decission

2) oldschool (my team) can only lose in such a situation. if theres a rematch and oldschool loses, they are out. If they win they ranked 2nd place (becouse sieg-geil won their directly match)... so they can only lose (ending at 2nd place playing a more difficult enemy).

3) oldscotch. if theres a rematch they can only win. they can end up at first place and getting easier enemy or ofcourse they can keep their 3rd place with a lose but then it would be "their own fault". i also totally agree with their oppinion to play another matches.

as this is still a part of group deciding games there cant be a draw so theres maybe a 2h+ Titan war game. And i think i will not play in a groupd phase match that long with also a bit of lotto (end game dead = 1min respawn). or just waiting till enemy is doing something wrong to counter them and killing base in one rush.
Thats a reason why we have a BO3 and the final (also BO3? - dont know right now). Especially when we end up in a worse place then if we dont want to play such a match.

ok thats just a oppinion right now and i prefer playing than calculating. but if one of the teams (sieg-geil) dont want to play as part of this "loop". It totally makes no sense to me of playing a decission round just for the two others of the loop.

this is no offense to any team or oli with his rulesBig Grin. its an oppinion and a drift of my thughts last 2 days.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
RE: [vote] K-D is a bad factor for ranking teams. Should we fix it now with rematch? - by gozo1985 - 2012-03-06, 18:20:26

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Keeping teams up / Team League? griffin1987 2 4,292 2012-03-08, 23:23:15
Last Post: progg



Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)