2010-08-25, 21:37:22
I carefully watched the replay about the fight between GEN_Schwarzkopf and xenocide85/General_Pwn.
The 3 replays are actually the same game, just recorded by different person:
General_PwnBan.w3g
BAN General_Pwn flamer.w3g
GEN_Schwarzkopf ip ban threat.w3g
(Actually at about 30min 40sec, yellow (richard_parker) already said something to green (the.x.rain) which deserves a ban. But later i realized they might know each other, so maybe it was a joke.)
The fight started when General_Pwn got the hunter, who asked his mates (firstly green, i.e. the.x.rain) to stand on the cp, so that the enemies will focus him, meanwhile General_Pwn can cast his ulti and smoke. I think this is not a smart idea, because buy a barri works the same. And there is no right for someone to ask other people to take this risk.
Then after several failed attempts, the.x.rain and general_pwn started fighting each other, and later GEN_Schwarzkopf involved as well. The game was ruined because of the flame.
However, to be fair I don't think general_pwn deserves a ban. Indeed, he said some fxxx words, and started the not wise attacking idea. But the thing is that the other people didn't said much less than general_pwn. Even in the post above GEN_Schwarzkopf is still using the "axxhxxx" word, which i don't see general_pwn keeps doing this (in public).
Maybe i am wrong. If possible i suggest make a vote ^_^ and let more people watch the replay and judge it.
The 3 replays are actually the same game, just recorded by different person:
General_PwnBan.w3g
BAN General_Pwn flamer.w3g
GEN_Schwarzkopf ip ban threat.w3g
(Actually at about 30min 40sec, yellow (richard_parker) already said something to green (the.x.rain) which deserves a ban. But later i realized they might know each other, so maybe it was a joke.)
The fight started when General_Pwn got the hunter, who asked his mates (firstly green, i.e. the.x.rain) to stand on the cp, so that the enemies will focus him, meanwhile General_Pwn can cast his ulti and smoke. I think this is not a smart idea, because buy a barri works the same. And there is no right for someone to ask other people to take this risk.
Then after several failed attempts, the.x.rain and general_pwn started fighting each other, and later GEN_Schwarzkopf involved as well. The game was ruined because of the flame.
However, to be fair I don't think general_pwn deserves a ban. Indeed, he said some fxxx words, and started the not wise attacking idea. But the thing is that the other people didn't said much less than general_pwn. Even in the post above GEN_Schwarzkopf is still using the "axxhxxx" word, which i don't see general_pwn keeps doing this (in public).
Maybe i am wrong. If possible i suggest make a vote ^_^ and let more people watch the replay and judge it.