Earthrobot - pls buff it somehow

[Althend]

the replay says "not downloaded yet" so how can you tell i could have done better with a different tank if you didn't even watch the replay? I respect your opinion and you're a really good player althend, but i don't see how the fuck i could have done much better than i did with that earth tank. I think earth tank was the perfect choice for me for that game. I'd respect your opinion a whole lot more if you watched the replay first before you made your coment. unless you got the replay from some one else.

It is not about the replay. I just don't see how you can base the opinion about the earth just on one replay. Your score is good but you don't explain why earth was the good choice bad with wich reason. I think you are a good player and you could take any tank/build to do good score, so one of your game is not relevant for me. It is what I mean with my comment. + it was Hb and you admit having a good start and you know that a good start is the most important in hb. I don't really care about replay, I trust you but I ask for real normal game/calculation point/argument.
I am sure than we all can get some replay where we own with some funny build, it still doesn't make them good ^_^

You say it is the best choice you had but tell us why?
I still don't see the real speciality of the earth and his real advantage to compensate his weakness : no stun, natural slow, skill implying weakness like slow and ultima making you stay still, ground skills only. (isn't this a lot?)